Work
Epstein and Helmut Kentler's Strongest Soldiers: Postcolonial Queer Theorists Romanticizing Abuse of Hijra Chelas
Author
Sahara Chowdhury
Archived
19 November 2026
Original source
Read on Google Docs

Epstein and Helmut Kentler's Strongest Soldiers: Postcolonial Queer Theorists Romanticizing Abuse of Hijra Chelas

In 2026, India passed a Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act[1], amending the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019[2]. The 2026 amendment act removes recognition of trans women and trans men, and legally recognizes only the ‘traditional’ gender-nonconforming identities such as kinner, hijra, aravani, or jogta.
In 2026, the Bangladeshi Education Minister Ehsanul Hoque Milon, also colloquially known as Helicopter Milon, accidentally made comments about making space for more transgender individuals in education, for which he promptly profusely apologized [3], clarifying that he did not mean to disrespect ‘social values’ and that he meant to say ‘third gender' rather than ‘transgender'.
On Dec. 21, 2023, a handful of Dhaka University students protested against the previously kept Transgender/Hijra quota, and with minimal pressure succeeded in persuading the University authorities to drop transgenders from it, the students clarified that they only oppose transgenders and do not oppose hijra people. [4]
These incidents are a select few examples of a wider pattern that has always been fairly common in Bangladesh and South Asia in general, where right wingers and centrists insist that they RESPECT hijras , but do not support transgenders- - under a rhetorical framing of hijras as intersex. Which, although affirmed by Bangladeshi laws defining hijras as intersex, does not represent the actual reality - - where they consist of both intersex people and gender nonconforming individuals who are not intersex - - some, who have undergone sex reassignment surgery or hormone replacement, some, who have not and nor intend to do so. The politicians know this.
The politicians’ stated support also does not exist in reality for the hijra underlings or chelas- - who mostly languish in doing sex work and begging - - which is often coerced by the gurumas for whom they generate profits. The politicians mostly collaborate with influential hijra gurumas who own large gharanas that hold a great many number of hijra chelas in servitude to the gurumas.
The amount of control that gurumas enjoy over their chelas' lives is politically favorable to the politicians, who only need to win over a hijra guruma’s support through future promises or by financial means to mobilize her chelas into campaigning or voting for them. As it happens, hierarchical gender systems are preferred by the state. The rhetorical framing of hijras as intersex also helps both the politicians and also hijra gurumas. As they can term any non-intersex hijra chela who attempts to stop being subservient to them as “fake hijra” and harass them through the media or cops. This “fake hijra” rhetoric, also allows gurumas to attack [5] any gender nonconforming or transgender person in the gurumas’ areas of control, who refuse to join their gharana or ‘house’ to generate profits for them through prostitution and begging. Here's a hyperlinked instagram video [6] containing one such incident, titled by the poster as “নকল হিজরা সেজে আসল হিজরার কাছে কট”, which translates to “Fake Hijra Gets Caught by Real Hijra”, these abuses are not exactly reported by mainstream media, nor documented by NGOs. This fake hijra rhetoric is also routinely utilized to attack rival hijra factions by accusing their gurumas of being “fake hijra”.

In my various texts, [7] [8] I argue that the purpose of homophobia and transphobia is to push queer children into prostitution- - and that both right wingers who profess to be anti-queer and self-proclaimed leftists or postcolonials who profess to be queer allies or even queer themselves but oppose legal rights work in tandem to keep this system of abuse smoothly running:

While gays are denied marriage rights due to not being reproductive, marriage's endgoal remains to maintain reproduction. Ideologies that are against letting homosexuals legally marry will inevitably allow child marriage and marital rape of cis girls and women and the pederasty and coerced prostitution of queers. Women are treated as reproductive properties. Due to this, rape is less a violation of the victim's body and more a trespassing onto the father's or the husband's property. Under this mindset, marital rape can not exist because the husband is the property owner and cannot trespass his own property, child marriage is acceptable as long as the child can birth babies because that's the condition of marriage being fulfilled. And because un-reproductive bodies are not marriageable, the femboys and trans women become un-rape-able even when they're funneled into prostitution as children and violated and penetrated against consent. By maintaining medical discrimination the ruling class ensures the early deaths of these prostitutes to keep the supply of flesh forever young and maintain the lack of life long formation of attachments. While the first world legalizes Igbt marriage, it utilizes NGOs and liberal intellectuals in the third world to argue against Igbt marriage rights due to depending on the labor of third worlds. As well as incentivizing third world queers to acquiesce to getting human trafficked by sex trafficking rings to first world countries hoping for freedom from bigotry.
"But won't homosexual marriage rights reinforce the patriarchal institution of marriage?"
I'm glad you asked! But no, it won't. Marriage is patriarchal due to it being designed as a ritual of reproduction. Reproduction legitimizes child marriage as long as the child bride gives birth. It legitimizes marital rape. Because gay relationships do not reproduce, marriage which for lgbts would be a ritual of social acknowledgement- actually subverts patriarchal values. Whereas without marriage, in secrecy lgbt relationships affirm patriarchal assignment of queers within the realm of secret hookups and prostitution. Saying marriage is capitalistic and patriarchal so gays shouldn’t get marriage rights is like saying "the state exists to protect capital so socialists shouldn’t want a socialist state".

The hijra traditions (although mainstream Bangladeshi media often prefers to hide the aspect of sex work and chooses to romanticize the feudal system as a precolonial testament to acceptance and tolerance and diversity and various other feel-good terms - - and prefers to only frame them as “beggars” or dancers or “entertainers”) largely involves forcing the younger Hijra chelas to do sex work to generate profits for the Hijra gurumas. Like an MLM pyramid scheme that involves human flesh as the products, if the chela manages to survive she may one day become a guruma herself and merrily go about her way to pimp out other destitute queer children who have suffered homelessness and lack education and employment opportunities. You understand, of course, that most hijra chelas do not become gurumas, just like how most workers do not become capitalists or millionaires by simply working really hard and having The Dream dangled in front of them out of reach. This system of bonded labor is romanticized by postcolonial queer theorists. Shamayeta Bhattacharya et al. writes in Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act’ of India: An Analysis of Substantive Access to Rights of a Transgender Community [9]:

The subclause 18 (a) of clause 8 of the Trans Act stated that ‘Whoever (a) compels or entices a transgender person to indulge in the act of begging or other similar forms of forced or bonded labor other than any compulsory service for public purposes imposed by Government’ will be criminalized. Framing begging as a ‘bonded labor’ is important discursively and performatively because it threatens to erase the history of hijras in India. The hijra community in India has historically lived as gharanas (big family) and each of the gharana members contributed financially for the sustenance of the gharana (Tapasya 2020). The gurus (mentor) train young chella (apprentice) hijras on how to ask for chola (alms) at several cultural occasions, and at trains, bus stops, and other landmark locations (Goel 2018; Sinha 2019). Once trained and having started earning, chellas were included in a gharana culture and had the right to inherit property from their mentors. The criminalization of begging made it difficult to earn money via this guru-chella system, exposing all hijra households to the risk of criminalization (Saria 2019), and threatened to wipe out centuries-old cultural and traditional practices of bonding, social support, and social capital.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHH! We can't have a ban on gurumas forcing chelas into bonded labor because of muh “centuries-old cultural and traditional practices of bonding”. The bill, for all its other faults, bans forced begging and bonded labor, not begging itself. But these postcolonial scholars refuse to even acknowledge how abusive these traditions the gender non-conforming people have been forced into are for them. The way the author frames it, as if most chelas get to inherit their gurumas' “property” is detached from reality. It’s an MLM pyramid scam, most don't live long enough to make it that far.
An article titled “Trafficking haunts transgender community” reads [10]:

These guru mafias are operating all over South Punjab. They coerce transgender persons into dancing and prostitution and even sell them for bids as high as Rs 10,000,000 by sharing seductive videos of their dances with potential bidders through social networking applications like WhatsApp. In case a transgender person dares to refuse the guru’s orders, they are ruthlessly battered to the point where some even lose their lives,” disclosed Nigaheen.

According to Saba Gul, a transgender rights activist associated with a non-governmental organisation (NGO), almost 3,469 incidents of violence against transgender individuals have been registered during the past five years, with many ending in the death of the victim.

A report titled Family bond or bonded labour: What ails the guru-chela relationship in the hijra community? [11] reads:

“My first guru was an alcoholic and would always create a scene,” she said. “She wouldn’t show up to important events and I was hurt and depressed. She harassed me for money and levelled allegations that I stole money, gold, etc.”

When Rose decided to run away, she said, her guru and a few of her chelas “kidnapped me, dragged me home, hit me with brooms and slippers, and even chopped my hair to brand me an offender”.
…
The rules that govern the community are not arbitrary. A jamaat or committee, constituting the nayaks from every city or town, is instated to enforce the rules and collect fines ranging from Rs 100 to Rs 1 lakh. These rules are likely not recorded; they are passed down traditionally to successive jamaats. Many gurus compel chelas to sever ties with their families, as they feel the latter can never truly accept trans children.
…
The rules are varied and strictly defined. “Entering a police station, for any purpose, invokes a fine,” said Kajal guru. “All disputes must be resolved internally, through the jamaat. Begging or collecting badhai (alms at events) outside one’s territory attracts severe penalties.”

These rules might seem excessive but they are necessary, according to Zara Siddiqui*, another Mumbai-based guru who lives with her own guru and two of her chelas.

“Disciplinary beatings are sometimes required,” said Zara, who is around 45 years old. “The new generation is greedy: they want to keep everything they earn. For us, everything is our guru’s and will eventually be passed down to us.”

While Rose says she would leave the system at the first real opportunity she gets, it’s almost unheard of to do so. “You usually get captured and punished. You cannot work in any of the community’s occupations without the affiliation of a guru and gharana” she said. “One can distance themselves gradually.”

…
Neysara, the founder of Transgender India, an online transgender community, said the hijra community is “not a child-friendly place equipped to handle trauma”. “What is vulnerable is traffickable,” she said, “and most that join are disenfranchised.”

She recalled being young and scared and turning to the hijra community, only to be met with its most “brutal side”. “When my family was trying to honour-kill me, I sought the hijra jamaat for help,” she said. “They outright told me that I can’t have a call centre job and could only stay with them if I do sex work and earn for them. The capital for the entire operation comes from traditional occupations, making everyone manpower.”

But no! This can't be called bonded labor or forced labor and nor be banned because our little wee Shamayeta Bhattacharya doesn’t want their precious fucking “centuries old traditions” to be threatened! We can't call marital rape “rape” because it might hurt the patriarch's feelings and we can't call bonded labor “bonded labor” because it might hurt the guruma's feelings!
The Family bond or bonded labour: What ails the guru-chela relationship in the hijra community? article goes on to say:

There will be a hundred opinions based on a hundred people’s experiences, and they are all valid,” said Sowmya Gupta, deputy program manager at Humsafar Trust, an organisation working to advance health, advocacy, capacity building & research for the LGBTQIA+ community. “But as the only structure resembling a family, it needs reform, not abolishment.”

Sowmya argued that even within families, collective earnings are handed to one person to budget for the entire household.

In response to that, I write in Homosexual Marriage versus Pedophiles:

Ah, yes, of course. As we know, it is very typical of “families” to routinely whore out the children. We can’t have marriage rights, and in the absence of marriage rights, we can have rape-families instead. Alternative family indeed, Epstein Island was a theme park with fun for the whole family too! Remember Helmut Kenter of Germany? The poststructuralist who put homeless boys in the “care” of pedophilic foster parents? Oddly enough I’m reminded of that particular atrocity in our precious little LOCAL INDIGENOUS rape culture. I remember particularly when the story of a Bangladeshi immigrant guruma [12] sex trafficking hundreds of trans people [13] over the border to India, and our lovely post-pedophiles defending her using identity politics. Suddenly the owner of private property and human capital became a subaltern. It reminds one of Jeffrey Epstein’s wife, oops I committed misogyny by identifying her by her husband’s name, sorry, Ghislaine Maxwell — child rapist— playing identity politics to say [14], “if you look at this crime, this overall crime, it’s all about men abusing women for a long period of time… and it’s only one person in jail — a woman”.
Equality win! The South Asian trans woman child rape accomplice with enough capital gets to play identity politics just like a white biological cis female child rape accomplice!

But hey, I'm sure that out of the hundreds of chelas that guruma sex trafficked, one would have eventually been able to become a guruma herself and inherit the child-prostitution money of the older guruma. And thus make all the abuse they went through okay according to postcolonials!
Post-colonial scholars and queer theorists love to swing between declaring the Hijra guru-chela hierarchy to be at once a radical and revolutionary alternative to traditional family structures, a queer found family and all that jazz — and upon being confronted with the exploitative nature of bonded labor, the pimping of young chelas and the exploitation, they declare "well, traditional families have abuses too."
Speaking of Ghislaine Maxwell, let's talk about another white woman, Liz Mount. Her works have two running themes 1) Transgender women's existence is inherently denigrating to hijras and 2) hijra gurumas should be allowed to abuse hijra chelas.

Liz Mount writes in “Rescuing the reformable: NGO interventions, queer necropolitics, and the criminalization of hijra families in India” [15]:

As hijra relationships come under scrutiny for the interpersonal violence that can occur in them, some hijras face criminalization. NGOs even sometimes intervene directly into hijra family disputes, criminalizing the (violent) behaviors of older hijras to protect younger hijras.
…
Dosti staff use criminalizing rhetoric and stories of violence to align hijra families with other groups perceived as violent and disorderly, constructing older hijras as “dangerous others,” and encouraging younger hijras to dissolve these relationships. These interventions into hijra families focus on the harms of interpersonal violence without adequately accounting for the social and economic context within which such violence occurs. While this process of criminalizing hijra families may alleviate the violence that some younger hijras face, it also disenfranchises older hijras, exposing them to increased structural (and police) violence.
…
While Dosti staffs' interventions may reduce violence some younger hijras face, they expose older hijras to increased structural (and police) violence. Thus, Dosti staff are complicit in shaping necropolitical “death worlds” inhabited by older hijras, who cannot rely on hijra support systems. Conflicts between hijras and Dosti reflect broader tensions between global NGO funding agendas and hijras' systems of care and livelihood. The criminalization of hijra practices and economic systems by Dosti staff can be understood as a necropolitical intervention exposing (especially older) hijras to increased state violence and structural precarity.

Social workers in the first world rescue children and human trafficking victims from abusive situations too, and they're often paid for it. Would Liz Mount prefer that Epstein's victims had not been separated from him, lest he suffered a grievous neck injury in his cell? Or maybe not, perhaps it’s the race, perhaps the bodies of brown gender nonconforming kids being perpetually abused tickles something in Miss Liz Mount.
Recently in Bangladesh, a hijra chela was set on fire by her guruma and died in agonizing pain [16], the hijra community rules would prevent another hijra chela from even reporting that to the police:

According to the case statement, between 9:00pm and 10:00pm on Wednesday (May 13), Guruma Zahir and associates allegedly tied up Mahi in front of their akhra (community home) at Burichang Uttar Bazar. They then poured kerosene and set Mahi on fire.
Locals rescued Mahi and first took them to Cumilla Medical College Hospital. Later, Mahi was transferred to National Burn Institute in Dhaka where they died under treatment.
The family alleged that local police were initially unwilling to accept the case.
Burichang Police Station OC told The Daily Star that Guruma Zahir had allegedly been operating a yaba trade and extortion racket from the akhra built on government land in Burichang Uttar Bazar for nearly one and a half years. Mahi was reportedly a member of that group.

Our Lady Liz Mount would prefer that this was never reported to begin with lest it had empowered the state. But perhaps the police were woke social justice warriors and an avid reader of her works, and thus they chose to initially respect the subalternity of the hijra guruma— who so bravely subverted the traditional gender norms of not setting people on fire and killing them to death— by being unwilling to accept the case.

Liz Mount is a transmisogynist in disguise. In her book "New" Women: Trans Women, Hijras, and the Remaking of Inequality in India, she argues the existence of trans women inherently creates a hierarchy positioning trans women above hijras. Her works frame trans women as bourgeoisie while calling hijra gurumas literally profiting off pimping chelas and making chelas beg as "working class”. Gurumas are, by Marxist definition, bourgeois, they literally profit off of the labor of chelas, even if the chelas weren’t being forced into prostitution as kids, even if it was more humane and they generated profit for gurumas by just dancing and collecting alms — that would still by definition classify the hijra gurumas as bourgeois. Class in Liz Mount's pedo-rapist framework though, becomes not about whether someone owns private property or whether they support themselves by selling their wage but whether the gender nonconforming person identifies as hijra or trans. A guruma making money by pimping chelas is considered to be "working class" rather than bourgeois due to being hijra- - and a trans woman selling her labor with no private property becomes "urban elite middle class" for not identifying as hijra.
In her text "I am Not a Hijra": Transgender Women Claiming Citizenship in South India [17], Liz Mount writes:

Through an 18-month ethnographic study conducted with hijras (gender non-conforming people assigned male at birth), newly emerging transwomen, and Dosti, a large NGO in Bangalore, India, this dissertation argues that transgender women claim citizenship by drawing distinct borders between themselves and hijras and positioning hijras as undeserving of the rights of citizenship, thus bolstering their own citizenship claims. This exploration of gender non-conforming people’s citizenship claims in the global South responds to a call for queer studies scholars to consider how citizenship operates among sexual and gender variant people in global South contexts (Richardson 2017). While the identity rubric of transgender is increasingly adopted by individuals in the global South, there is limited research about the empowering and disempowering effects of these identity shifts (Dutta & Roy 2014: 498). By analyzing transwomen’s citizenship claims, my research illustrates the ways that “publics are seduced into viewing some as less than human and come to consent to their banishment from this category and its benefits” (Haritaworn 2015: 129). Though this dissertation focuses primarily on transwomen’s efforts to distinguish themselves from hijras as a way to claim citizenship, there are many other sexual minority groups who seek to distance themselves from hijras, including even hijras.
…
While I present evidence of a series of activist projects that do not necessarily seek inclusion into normative citizenship (West 2014) via the exclusion of others, this dissertation ultimately argues that by aspiring to become citizens, transwomen have reinforced the exclusion of hijras, thus, this form of inclusion is “murderous” (Haritaworn et al. 2013). My analysis is aligned with Brandzel (2016), Spade (2015) and Haritaworn (2013 & 2015), among others, who assert that citizenship operates as an exclusionary category and should therefore be understood as antithetical to social justice struggles.

Liz Mount admits that trans women "do not necessarily seek inclusion into normative citizenship via exclusion of others" but insists that trans women wanting citizenship at all inherently dehumanizes Hijras.
Liz Mount claims transgender women are hierarchical over hijra identities, while insisting that the hierarchical guru-chela bonded labor structure must be preserved. While politicians say "we support hijras but hate transgenders", while the Indian state itself wipes out trans identities and keeps only traditional gender identities legalized.
Trans women cannot have legal recognition or employment according to these people, somehow having employment outside prostitution and begging in bonded labor makes someone not be “working class” anymore and the pimp gurumas making money off pimping homeless queer children are the real “working class.” Freedom is slavery, slavery is emancipation. I mean, gee, Liz. Who funds you? Did your Epstein overlord's supply of child prostitutes dry up a little to make you this mad at trans women?
It's not like they deny it either. They don't claim that gurumas don't force the chelas into sex work or begging. They brazenly admit that the abuse and forced labor goes on and then they argue against intervening on the abuse and forced labor or illegalizing it by calling it 'forced labor' anyway.
They simply don't have to deny it, because the trans girls are not human in their eyes and might as well get violated if it generates for the gurumas a bit more profit so they can feel woke and inclusive about bringing the gurumas to their seminars and write soliloquies about destroying the gender binary.
Liz Mount's CV [18] states her next work in progress projects are titled “Crisis' Activism: Working-class Lesbians and Transgender Men Mobilizing through Crisis in South India” and “Visibility' and Rights: Working-class Lesbians and Transgender Men 'At Risk' in South India”. Well, I'm glad transgender men are allowed to be “working class” unlike the evil upperclass elite transgender women who oppress hijras simply by existing and demanding legal rights! Although I'm not sure all trans men would appreciate being grouped with lesbian women. But what do I know, I'm just a privileged bourgeois!
This framing of trans women who do not identify as hijra to be “privileged elite bourgeois neo-liberal” et cetera other buzzwords is pretty common. In Representing the Hijras of South Asia: Toward Transregional and Global Flows [19], Aniruddha Dutta, Adnan Hossain (take a note of Mister Adnan here), and Claire Pamment write:

On another front, 'transgender' also becomes positioned as an aspirational cate-gory associated with assimilation into the mainstream and social respectability, while hijra practices that often subvert social morality and caste/class-based notions of respectability become positioned as even more abject (Mount, 2020; Pamment, 2019b; Dutta, 2012b). The celebration of transgender pioneers in mainstream spheres has sometimes served to malign hijra practices as "stereotypes" or communitarian baggage; transgender becomes positioned as a model of self-fashioning into neoliberal ideals of productivity and professional respectability, stigmatizing or erasing hijra strategies of resistance (Mount, 2020; Pamment, 2019a, b).
Such hierarchies have been reinforced in legal discourses of transgender rights.
The 2016 version of the Indian Transgender bill contained explicit provisions against "begging" (framed as "forced or bonded labor") which could criminalize hijra occupational and performance practices and associated guru-chela relations (Saria, 2019). The 2019 Indian Act has removed direct references to begging but retained the clause against "forced or bonded labor" which may continue such criminalization indirectly. Meanwhile, the Pakistani Act remains explicitly punitive about begging (Redding, 2019). Apart from occupational practices, the legal recognition of hijras as transgender does not adequately recognize, and potentially criminalizes, hijra forms of kinship in favor of heterosexual modes of family, further extending biopolitical surveillance over these communities (Saria, 2019).

Hijra practices that subvert social morality and caste/class-based notions of respectability? A demographic being trapped in prostitution to generate profits for gurumas who can abuse them at will subverts the caste system? Why? Because the prostitutes are being raped in the ass instead of the pussy? “Transgender becomes positioned as a model of self-fashioning into neoliberal ideals of productivity”. Because don't want to be ass-raped to generate profits for gurumas who will burn them alive at fancy? “South Asian trans women (who are bourgeoisie, neo-liberal, classist and imperialist) refuse to generate profits for pimps by being raped for money. This is because they have not properly decolonized their minds.”
In Imaginary Maps By Mahasweta Devi, she illustrated how bonded labor mechanism is used to keep women trapped in forced sex work and repeatedly raped. This was a seminal work of postcolonial literature. But these people? They're using postcolonialism to argue in favor of keeping bonded labor alive to get hijra people raped under guruma authority in prostitution and begging. Or is it woke because the victim is a hijra chela or a trans woman insread of a cis woman? Representation win?
By the way, hijra is not simply a word. If a trans woman chose to identify as hijra without joining a hijra gharana under bonded labor, these people would be the first to accuse her of appropriating the hijra culture. And even beyond that, as established previously, there's a “fake hijra” [20] narrative that gurumas utilize to attack rival factions and any gender-non-conforming person independent of hijra gharanas. Being a trans woman without joining a hijra gharana while staying in areas where hijra gurumas have influence is inherently risky, but embracing the hijra identity without joining the abusive bonded labor system of sex work and begging is downright asking for abuse. So what should trans women do? Why don't you say it? Why do you need to use so much bullshit fucking crap and act like social justice warriors? You want to rape trans women for cheap money in secrecy. If it means forever segregating them into prostitution then so be it. Say it! Stop the LARP and just say it, motherfucker!
Adnan Hossain (remember?) in his book. Beyond Emasculation: Pleasure and Power in the Making of Hijra in Bangladesh, referring to physical and medical transitions including hormone use, orchiectomy, and gender reassignment as "emasculation” - - writes that those are not what makes a hijra, that the hijra identity is really about the “profession”. The sex work and the begging. He writes that they should not be described as transgender.
So why call trans women classist for not wanting to identify as hijra? There is a contradiction inherent to these people, who at once insist hijra identity is not synonymous to transgender, that it is a profession but also that trans women are elitist and classist so they don't identify with this profession that is not synonymous to their identity, but also that precolonial cultures were accepting because these professions existed. How is transaction acceptance?
Adnan Hossain in his book Beyond Emasculation: Pleasure and Power in the Making of Hijra in Bangladesh, writes:

While the guru may seem like the tyrannical patriarch of a hijra house, the relationship between a cela and their guru is based on mutual respect, care, love and trust. Although the will of a guru reigns supreme in the hijra hierarchy, it is not an exploitative arrangement with gurus enjoying the benefits at the expense of the celas. Rather, this hierarchical configuration enables a division of labour with both guru and cela having a specific set of tasks, the undertaking of which is central to the maintenance of the hijra status quo.

The immediate next paragraphs in his book are:

While the guru–cela relationship is based on mutual respect and reciprocity, it is also at times fraught with tension. For instance, in the event of an infringement of a code of conduct, a hijra may be subjected to stringent punishment. The nature of the punishment hinges upon the severity of the offence. The accused is at best fined, or at worst excommunicated. During my fieldwork, I saw two such incidents. Once it so happened that a cela was found to be sexually involved with the husband of a guru. As a punishment, the accused had to have their head totally shaved before being kicked out of the group (I discuss the partners of the hijras in chapter 6). The second incident took place after a cela underwent emasculation without the permission of a guru but was later reincorporated by paying a ‘don’ or penalty (see chapter 4 on emasculation). Aside from such serious infractions, penalties for petty crimes include paying a don, or in some cases ‘chol pani bondh’ (an enforced period of fasting). Once chol pani bondh is imposed, it is only the guru who reserves the right to lift it. Once the ban is lifted, the guru embraces the cela and feeds them with their own hand.

Adnan Hossain just described seeing chelas getting their head forcibly shaved and other chelas undergoing forced starvation and denial of water as punishment. Being denied water and food for extended periods of time and then being fed by the person who forced you to undergo starvation and thirst is literal enforced trauma bonding. Hey, Adnan, Adnan, you fucking pig, do you have diabetes? Can I starve you and deny you water for an extended period of time if you promise not to take legal actions against me, dipshit? I’ll feed you by hand if you survive.
Another excerpt from Adnan Hossain's book:

Rani, a hijra guru, organized a festival on the occasion of the initiation of a new cela. Hijras from not only outside Dhaka, but as far afield as Barashat in India were invited. Since influential hijras from several different places were present and because some of them might object to the presence of an outsider like me, Rina asked me to write the contract for the initiation and keep a record of the amount of money given by the guests. As several daratnis—the hijra word for leaders—assembled in the room, Rina handed me a 100 taka (roughly US$1.26) notarized government stamp paper. A hijra named Siraj Master dictated while I scribbled. The contract, which I later photocopied from Rina, is reproduced below in translation, with the original names changed:

I, Sadia hijra (Father: Moshrraf, Mother: Monira, Village: Mithakhali, District: Kurigram) hereby declare that I am accepting the discipleship of guru Trishna Hijra of 1/a, Topkhana Road, Segunbagicha, Dhaka-1000 (Guru: Rina hijra, dad guru: Jomuna hijra,) and Nan guru: Rina hijra (Guru: Jomuna Hijra, 28/2, Sohag vila, 1 no college road, Asrafabad Kamrangirchar, Dhaka). I also declare that if I ever join another hijra house, leaving my guru and the house of Rina, I will be liable to pay a don of 100,000 taka in keeping with the hijra pon-pesha/code of conduct.

The above contract was signed by Nadia, the initiand, along with six hijra witnesses. The contents of the contract not only illustrate the importance of the guru in the life cycle of a hijra, but also the binding nature of such discipleship. Trishna, the guru of Nadia, is known by their guru and grand guru, as the contract shows, as is Rina, the guru of Trishna in whose household the festival took place. Although the hijra initiating a cela typically sponsors such an event, in this case it was Rina hijra, the guru of Trishna, who was the sponsor. The reason the initiation took place at Rina’s khol (house) is because Trishna was not a full-time sadrali but a bagicha koti who lived with their natal family. The contract also shows that despite the binding nature of this contract, Nadia is allowed to change their guru and move into a new house— however, such a decision entails the settlement of the agreed don
…
Although a cela can change guru by paying the agreed amount, in the case of Nadia it may be very difficult, given the size of the amount. A ‘don’, the hijra word for penalty or compensation, can be much lower or higher than this. Hijras in Hridoypur maintained that it was around one lac taka (around US$1,000) in the case of their grand guru Jomuna, while the don for other initiations I attended ranged between 5,000 and 20,000 taka (roughly US$60–250). When a cela changes to a new house, the sponsoring guru pays the amount to the old guru. Celas, however, rarely change houses and when they do, it is often due to severe problems of adjustment.

But we can't call this bonded labor, folks! This is totally subverting “caste/class-based notions of respectability”! I. Do I need to analyze that? Do I need to explain to you how it's slavery? Throughout his book he voyeuristically writes on and on and on about the sexual pleasures of hijra chelas and mentions these abuses with rose tinted glasses without an ounce of material analysis to spare.
He is so fucking OBSESSED with insisting and insisting and insisting that “Hijras are not victims” that he actively glosses over violence and abuse and exploitation. “Despite the binding nature of this contract, Nadia is allowed to change their guru and move into a new house” he says, while simply washing off his hand at “however it might be difficult”.
“Errm yeah bro, the slave can technically buy their freedom. Difficult though. But they're not victims though.” How about I bust your kneecaps with a crowbar and you heal them with some difficulty?
Fetishized beyond fetishized, the gender nonconforming person getting routinely raped to generate profits for the guruma becomes an object to which celebrate a non-existence “sexual agency” and “subversion of social morals” with. No, the social morals do not prohibit these things because the purpose of society in its treatment of gender nonconforming people, the state and religious mechanisms is precisely to keep them trapped in sexual slavery without legal recognition. The purpose of a system is what it does, and its purpose is keeping LGBT people trapped in secretive prostitution.
Adnan Hossain reproduces a statement from a Hijra sex worker in his book:

I will now tell you about how to have safe sex with a panthi. We all know that panthis often object to condoms as they think condoms will lower their pleasure. And we all know they refer to jhalka [money] when asked to use a condom. ‘Why should I put on that? I have paid you. So you must let me do you in whatever way I want,’ says a typical panthi, but there are still ways to deceive them into having sex with the condoms on. And I will show you how. Whenever you have sex with a panthi, start with your mouth. Take the condom inside your mouth and then suck the penis slowly and in the process you will see that his penis is erect and also sucked. And then play.

The sex worker basically has to trick her dipshit clients into using condoms because they feel like they own her.
And then Adnan Hossain goes on to later write:

While I do not contest the wider societal denigration associated with the receptive status and the production of gender in such erotic encounters, it would be reductive to assume that this disproportionate power dynamic structures the lived erotic practices between hijras and their panthis. In other words, despite the wider societal valorization of penetration, penetrators do not necessarily exercise greater dominance in the actual erotic play. Rather, based on my interaction with hijras, I would argue that the power dynamics in actual sexual practice is often if not always reversed, with hijras taking the style and position of a stereotypical masculine man. The ethnographic episodes mentioned earlier about the hijra sense of discomfort and embarrassment about genital status expressed in relation to their partners indicate that my interlocutors often dominated the actual play in terms of determining what could and could not be done during sex.

Sure, you piece of fucking shit, the people trapped in bonded labor having to trick their clients into wearing a fucking condom to avoid STDs is dominating play because you can't admit for one fucking second that abuse is going on. There is no war in Ba Sing Se! There is no war in Ba Sing Se! There is no war in Ba Sing Se!
Where as notable trans female figures like Joya Sikder describe being repeatedly sexual assaulted at her workplace and the trauma leading to her joining hijra communes and doing sex work [21] [22], people like Adnan Hossain decry the very notion of hijra people suffering abuse or being portrayed as victims as oppressive in itself.
And so the Mahi hijras shall continue to be forced to sign themselves into slavery, be starved, denied water, raped, and then be set on fire. Because acknowledging the exploitation would mean that South Asians on twitter wouldn’t be able to brag about how their culture respects the third gender just like how Islam has given women the highest wrung of respect. And any attempt at acknowledging it will be dismissed as neo-liberal, bourgeois etc. While the Adnan Hossains preach for secrecy [23] in the fear of a “homocolonial backlash”, somehow that will not register as middle class respectability politics to them - - while they dismiss critique of gurumas committing abuses on hijra chelas as middle class respectability politics. While the Adnan Hossains fearmonger about Xulhaz and Tonoy getting killed and refer to it as homocolonial backlash, innumerable Hijra chelas were murdered by their clients, guruma pimps, and in hate crimes. But the Adnan Hossains will continue to preach for secrecy while that culture of secrecy puts the visibly queer more at risk, and then the Adnan Hossains will reject the very notion of an at risk demographic as disrespectful to said demographic. While Adnan Hossain claims NGOs giving safe sex education to Hijra prostitutes disrespects the hijras, or Liz Mount claims trying to remove younger hijra chelas from abusive gurumas is laced with financial incentives. They'll continue to get fat on their research grants while keeping alive the stagnant status quo of zero political progress for LGBTs so that they keep getting that sweet sweet green.
Below is a list of the grants received by Adnan Hossain in the last five years:

2025: Principal Investigator. Countering anti-(trans)gender politics in Asia. Total amount £ 132723. Funded by GFW.

2024: Principal Investigator. Transforming politics: Strengthening trans political activism and leadership in the Global South. Total amount £ 141955. Funded by OSF.

2024: Personal Research Allowance. Total amount £2000. Funded by School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Glasgow.

2022: Climate-change Induced Immobility (CLIMO): Investigating the Historical, Socio-cultural, and Political Interlinkages (With Bishawjit Mallick & Ajay Bailey). Total amount € 10,000. Funded by Utrecht University.

2022: Travel and conference award. Total amount € 2500. Funded by Utrecht University.

2021: “Intersex justice in South Asia: A comparative review” (with Prashant Singh & Nikoletta Pikramenou), funded by WFD (Westminster Foundation for democracy). Total amount: £10,000.

2021: Project Co-Director. Contract from the Canadian High Commission in Bangladesh to develop a research summary and policy suggestions for the Canadian LGBTQ advocacy plan in Bangladesh. December 2020-May 2021. Value of contract: $8000.

2020: “Trans and hijra lives in times of Corona” in the Netherlands and Bangladesh, funded by ShareNet International. Total award €20,000.

Indeed, indeed! The funds should go to researchers like you instead of being wasted on educating at-risk prostitutes about safe sex, consent and STDs, right, Adnan? Here's a poem dedicated to you:

They teach anti-materialism and
Moderation to the slaves, they demand
For the element of "pharmakon" to
Be introduced and "destabilize" too
The "binary opposition" between
The pedophile rapist nonce and the teen.
And they find newer yet ways to decree
How radical, how transformative be
The myriad ways they breathe, eat and shit
How all things they do is a fatal hit
To the face of capital and the west
While they molest their housemaids and vest
Control of the nation's soil and seas
To the highest bidder, but be at ease:
"The sodomized orifices of kids
Represent the true resistance that rids
The colonizing Age of Consent laws,
Saves our nation from hegemony's jaws."

The NGO-cucked LGBT community's goal (and yes, that includes Adnan, the Giga NGO Cuck, no matter how much he pretends to criticize NGOs), is to buy “social acceptance” for ass fucking through hijra people. This is why they'll keep covering up the abuses.

  1. https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-transgender-persons-protection-of-rights-amendment-bill-2026
  2. https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-transgender-persons-protection-of-rights-bill-2019
  3. https://bdfeministarchives.org/2026/11/01/ekjon-shikkhamontrir-rajnoitik-obosthan-poribortoner/
  4. https://76crimes.com/2023/12/28/transgender-admissions-quota/
  5. https://bdfeministarchives.org/2024/06/01/remembering-a-brave-transwoman-utso-islam-mondal/
  6. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DdoXmZpDT2t/?lqvp=MTVmdXo1aTh2eDFjdA==
  7. https://thotkata.com/2026/06/19/homosexual-marriage-versus-pedophiles/
  8. https://archive.org/details/bangladeshi-queer-manifesto-a-manifesto-on-queer-vigilantism-by-sahara-chowdhury/mode/1up
  9. https://academic.oup.com/jhrp/article-abstract/14/2/676/6566269q
  10. https://tribune.com.pk/story/2437781/trafficking-haunts-transgender-community
  11. https://www.newslaundry.com/2021/04/14/family-bond-or-bonded-labour-what-ails-the-guru-chela-relationship-in-the-hijra-community
  12. https://www.lokmattimes.com/mumbai/bangladeshi-transgender-guru-maa-arrested-in-mumbai-for-living-on-fake-documents-suspected-of-bringing-over-200-people-to-india-illegally-a522/
  13. https://odishabytes.com/mumbais-transgender-guru-maa-turns-out-to-be-bangladeshi-arrested-and-charged-with-trafficking/
  14. https://www.news24.com.au/world/longtime-associate-of-jeffrey-epstein-breaks-silence-over-release-of-documents-unsealed-by-united-states-court/news-story/aaf4c6fd10ae0dc5a1470934d6da6103
  15. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S027753952500072X
  16. https://www.thedailystar.net/news/crime-justice/news/hijra-person-dies-after-being-torched-4178296
  17. https://surface.syr.edu/record/8538?ln=en&v=pdf
  18. https://www.depts.ttu.edu/sasw/majors/sociology/socfaculty/CV/CV_Mount.pdf
  19. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-03792-4_6
  20. https://www.banglatribune.com/national/352779/%E0%A6%A8%E0%A6%95%E0%A6%B2-%E0%A6%B9%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%9C%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%81%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%A7%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%AC%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%B8%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%A5%E0%A6%BE-%E0%A6%9A%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F-%E0%A6%86%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE
  21. https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/g0fgxhhtxn
  22. https://share-netbangladesh.org/transgender-and-hijra-is-not-the-same-says-joya-sikder/
  23. https://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/socialpolitical/staff/adnanhossain/#grants